Improvidently Granted: Surprise Early Victory from US Supreme Court for Oklahoma Women’s Rights

7526267232_4db2d935a8_c

Used under creative commons licence, copyright to image held by Mark Fischer on flickr @ http://www.flickr.com/photos/fischerfotos/7526267232/

In a surprising early turn of events, the US Supreme Court has dismissed Oklahoma’s appeal against a December 2012 ruling by the Oklahoma Supreme Court which struck down a ban on medication abortions as unconstitutional.

As you may recall, on Tuesday, the Oklahoma Supreme Court responded to questions posed to it by the US Supreme Court, seeking clarification on its interpretation of the impact of the law on Oklahoma women. Following this, it was expected that the case would then proceed to securing a place on the SCOTUS hearing docket this or next term.

This afternoon however, SCOTUS has dismissed Oklahoma’s case, stating in one single, elegant line that

“[t]he writ of certiorari is dismissed as improvidently granted”.

This effectively means that following a reading of Oklahoma’s answers, the US Supreme Court has changed its mind on granting Oklahoma the right to appeal, stating that it should not have accepted the case. Oklahoma’s case is therefore dismissed, and the original Supreme Court of Oklahoma’s ruling that the 2011 Oklhamoma law banning off-label use of abortion drugs was unconstitutional is upheld.

Given the legal events of the last two weeks, this is a fantastic win for women’s reproductive health and protection of Oklahoma women’s constitutionally protected rights.

Today’s US Supreme Court ruling in full (all one line of it) can be found here.